Cedar roofs offer natural beauty and long-term durability, but like any roofing material, they come with their own set of trade-offs. If you’re weighing your options, understanding the pros and cons of cedar roofing will help you make a confident, informed decision. From sustainability to maintenance, there are many considerations for cedar roofing that impact performance, longevity, and value.
In this blog, we’ll dive into the advantages of cedar roofing, its potential drawbacks, and what to expect if you’re thinking about installing a cedar roof. Whether you’re renovating an older home or building new in Minnesota, this comprehensive guide is built to support your decision-making process.
What Is Cedar Roofing?
Cedar roofing typically comes in two main styles: cedar shakes and cedar shingles. Both are crafted from natural cedar wood—most commonly Western Red Cedar or White Cedar—and offer distinctive aesthetic appeal along with natural insulation and weather resistance.
- Cedar Shakes: Thicker, rougher, and more rustic in appearance, typically hand-split.
- Cedar Shingles: Thinner and more uniform, usually machine-cut for a refined look.
Cedar has long been used in residential construction because of its durability and appearance. But understanding the considerations for cedar roofing goes beyond just curb appeal—it also includes performance, maintenance, and cost.
The Advantages of Cedar Roofing
1. Timeless Curb Appeal
Among the top advantages of cedar roofing is its classic, natural appearance. Cedar ages gracefully, transitioning from warm reddish-brown tones to a silvery gray over time.
Its distinctive texture and color variation can elevate the visual appeal of homes in a variety of architectural styles, from cottages to contemporary builds.
2. Natural Insulation
Cedar roofs are known for their thermal efficiency, helping regulate indoor temperatures throughout the year. This can result in:
- Reduced energy use
- Lower heating and cooling bills
- More consistent interior comfort
According to the U.S. Department of Energy, improving your home’s roof insulation is one of the most effective ways to boost energy efficiency (energy.gov).
3. Durability in Various Climates
Cedar is naturally resistant to many of the challenges posed by the climate in places like Minnesota. These include:
- Wind resistance: Cedar shakes and shingles can withstand strong winds when properly installed.
- Impact resistance: Cedar is more resilient than asphalt shingles against hail and debris.
- Pest resistance: The oils in cedar naturally repel insects like termites.
4. Environmentally Friendly Material
Cedar is a renewable resource. When harvested responsibly, it offers a sustainable roofing option. Many cedar products come from certified forests, and the wood is biodegradable.
Plus, cedar roofs can be recycled into mulch or other wood products at the end of their lifecycle, keeping them out of landfills.
You can explore forest sustainability certifications via the Forest Stewardship Council (FSC) at fsc.org.
5. Longevity with Proper Maintenance
With the right care, cedar roofs can last 30 to 40 years or more, making them a durable long-term investment. Their performance, however, depends heavily on regular upkeep, as discussed in the next section.
Drawbacks and Considerations for Cedar Roofing
While there are many reasons to love cedar, there are also important considerations for cedar roofing that might influence whether it’s the best fit for your home.
1. Maintenance Requirements
One of the most notable cons of cedar roofing is the need for consistent maintenance. Unlike synthetic materials or metal roofing, cedar is organic and naturally vulnerable to the elements.
Routine maintenance typically includes:
- Removing moss, algae, and debris
- Periodic cleaning
- Application of preservatives or treatments to prolong roof life
Without upkeep, cedar can become prone to rot, mold, and deterioration—especially in wet or humid climates.
2. Cost of Installation
Cedar roofing is significantly more expensive than asphalt shingles. Costs can vary depending on the style (shakes vs. shingles), roof size, and labor rates. On average:
- Cedar Shingles: $6–$9 per square foot installed
- Cedar Shakes: $7–$12 per square foot installed
These costs are justified by the roof’s natural beauty and potential for long-term performance, but homeowners should be prepared for a higher upfront investment.
3. Fire Risk (Without Treatment)
Natural wood is combustible. While some cedar roofing products are treated with fire retardants, untreated cedar can pose a fire hazard in wildfire-prone areas.
Homeowners may need to install fire-resistant barriers or opt for Class A fire-rated treated cedar materials to comply with local codes.
For more information on fire-safe building materials, check out the National Fire Protection Association (NFPA) at nfpa.org.
4. Moisture Sensitivity
In areas with high humidity or frequent rainfall, cedar roofs are more prone to water-related damage. While cedar is naturally resistant to moisture, over time, poor drainage or ventilation can lead to:
- Rot
- Swelling
- Warping
Ensuring your roof has proper ventilation and regular inspections is essential to prevent moisture damage and maintain longevity.
How Cedar Roofing Performs in Minneapolis
Minnesota’s climate is unique—cold winters, humid summers, and storm activity all play a role in roof performance. Understanding how cedar roofing holds up in these conditions is a key part of the decision process.
1. Cold Weather Resilience
Cedar roofs are naturally insulating, making them ideal for cold weather. They help keep your home warmer in winter and cooler in summer.
With proper installation and maintenance, cedar roofing can withstand snow accumulation, freeze-thaw cycles, and ice dams common in Minneapolis.
2. Wind and Storm Resistance
Thanks to their density and thickness, cedar shakes and shingles provide a high level of protection against wind uplift and impact, particularly when installed with stainless steel fasteners and correct spacing.
Is Cedar Roofing the Right Choice for You?
Choosing the right roofing material involves weighing appearance, performance, budget, and local conditions. Based on the pros and cons of cedar roofing, it’s a great option for:
✅ Homeowners who value natural aesthetics and curb appeal
✅ Those willing to invest in long-term performance
✅ Households prepared for regular roof maintenance
✅ Homeowners looking for sustainable materials
✅ Properties in moderate to cold climates like Minneapolis
If you’re looking for a roof that stands out for its elegance and delivers reliable performance with proper care, cedar roofing could be the perfect match.
Let Four Point Construction Help You Make the Right Choice
At Four Point Construction, we bring years of roofing expertise and a commitment to craftsmanship on every project. Whether you’re considering cedar shingles for their look or evaluating all your roofing options, we’ll help you navigate the considerations for cedar roofing specific to your home and climate.
Why Work With Us?
🔹 Expert cedar roof installation
🔹 Local Minneapolis experience
🔹 Clear pricing and honest recommendations
🔹 High-quality materials from trusted sources
🔹 Preventive maintenance and inspection services
Ready to Explore Cedar Roofing?
Cedar roofing can add natural beauty, long-term performance, and value to your home—but it’s important to know what to expect. Let Four Point Construction evaluate your roof and help you decide if cedar is right for your needs.
Get a free inspection now and take the first step toward a beautiful, long-lasting cedar roof.
