Cedar roofing myths have circulated for years, creating confusion and hesitation among homeowners considering this classic roofing material. While cedar shakes and shingles are known for their natural beauty and impressive performance, misinformation has led many to overlook this durable and eco-friendly option.
In this blog, we’ll break down some of the most common cedar roofing misconceptions, clear up the confusion, and offer facts that help you make a well-informed decision about your next roof upgrade. Whether you’re restoring a historic home or building new, it’s time to separate fact from fiction.
Understanding the Appeal of Cedar Roofing
Before we dig into the myths, it’s helpful to understand why cedar roofing has remained a popular choice for centuries. Cedar offers:
- A timeless aesthetic with a warm, natural appearance
- Excellent insulation, reducing energy costs
- Long-term durability when properly maintained
- Sustainability, as it comes from renewable sources
Despite these benefits, some common misunderstandings have given cedar roofing an undeserved reputation in certain circles.
Cedar Roofing Myths: Let’s Set the Record Straight
Myth #1: Cedar Roofs Are Not Durable
Truth: One of the most common cedar roofing misconceptions is that cedar can’t hold up to harsh weather or time. In reality, cedar roofs can last 30 to 40 years, and sometimes longer with regular maintenance and proper installation.
Cedar contains natural oils that resist moisture, decay, and insect damage. This gives it a natural advantage over some other roofing materials, especially in moderate to cold climates.
Proper ventilation, routine cleaning, and treatment with preservatives extend the roof’s life significantly. Many homeowners in Minnesota and other regions with tough weather rely on cedar for its strength and thermal performance.
Myth #2: Cedar Roofing Is a Fire Hazard
Truth: While untreated cedar wood is combustible, most cedar roofing today is pressure-treated with fire-retardant chemicals, giving it a Class B or even Class A fire rating when installed with an approved underlayment.
Fire resistance is a key topic in roofing, especially in wildfire-prone areas. According to the U.S. Fire Administration, roofing materials play a critical role in slowing the spread of fire (usfa.fema.gov). Cedar roofing, when properly treated, meets the fire resistance standards required by building codes in many jurisdictions.
It’s important to choose certified cedar products and a reputable installer to ensure compliance with local fire safety standards.
Myth #3: Cedar Roofing Is High Maintenance
Truth: Another widespread myth is that cedar roofing is too demanding to maintain. The reality is, all roofing materials require maintenance, and cedar is no exception—but it’s not nearly as high maintenance as many people believe.
Regular inspections, removing debris, and applying treatments every few years are usually enough to keep a cedar roof in top condition. Plus, individual cedar shingles or shakes can be replaced easily if damaged, without needing to redo large portions of the roof.
The National Park Service, in their preservation briefs, notes that cedar is a practical, maintainable material used in historic preservation projects (nps.gov). That level of trust speaks volumes about its long-term value.
Myth #4: Cedar Roofs Rot Easily in Moist Climates
Truth: It’s true that moisture is a concern for all wood products, but well-installed and properly ventilated cedar roofs resist rot far better than many assume.
Cedar’s natural oils prevent fungal growth and slow moisture absorption. The key is ensuring the roof is:
- Properly ventilated to allow drying
- Installed with adequate spacing for airflow
- Regularly cleaned of moss and debris
With these steps in place, cedar roofs can thrive in wetter climates. Preventative maintenance is the secret to avoiding moisture-related issues.
Myth #5: Cedar Roofing Isn’t Eco-Friendly
Truth: Cedar is actually one of the most environmentally friendly roofing materials available. It is biodegradable, recyclable, and sourced from renewable forests.
Many cedar products are certified by the Forest Stewardship Council (FSC) or similar organizations, ensuring sustainable harvesting practices. Unlike synthetic roofing, cedar doesn’t require energy-intensive manufacturing and leaves a smaller carbon footprint.
If you’re seeking a green building material, cedar is an excellent choice that aligns with environmentally conscious construction.
Myth #6: Cedar Roofs Don’t Work in Cold Climates Like Minneapolis
Truth: Cedar is an ideal roofing material for colder climates, including places like Minneapolis. Its thermal properties provide insulation that helps maintain consistent indoor temperatures, making it energy efficient during harsh winters.
Cedar roofs can handle snow loads, ice buildup, and freezing temperatures when installed correctly. Their thickness and density also provide good resistance to wind and hail, which are common concerns in northern regions.
Cedar’s natural resilience to the elements makes it especially valuable in areas where roofs must stand up to seasonal extremes.
Myth #7: Cedar Roofing Is Too Expensive for Most Homeowners
Truth: While the initial cost of cedar roofing is higher than asphalt shingles, the long-term return often makes it more affordable than you might think.
Here’s why:
- Longer lifespan: Cedar lasts 2–3 times longer than asphalt.
- Energy savings: Natural insulation helps reduce heating and cooling costs.
- Higher resale value: Homes with cedar roofing often appraise higher due to its premium aesthetic.
In the long run, the investment in cedar pays off in durability, energy efficiency, and visual appeal—often outweighing the initial price tag.
Why Clearing Up Cedar Roofing Myths Matters
Understanding the truth behind cedar roofing misconceptions helps homeowners make confident, informed choices. Choosing a roofing material is a significant decision—one that affects your home’s protection, efficiency, and appearance for decades.
By debunking myths, we hope to help you see cedar roofing not just as a luxury material, but as a high-performance, sustainable solution that works well in a variety of climates and architectural styles.
So, Is Cedar Roofing Right for You?
That depends on your preferences, priorities, and budget. Cedar roofing might be the right choice if you’re looking for:
✅ A timeless, natural look that enhances curb appeal
✅ A durable roof that performs in extreme weather
✅ An eco-friendly material that supports sustainability
✅ A long-term investment in your home’s value and energy efficiency
While it may not be for everyone, clearing up cedar roofing myths allows you to evaluate the option on its true merits—not on outdated assumptions.
How Four Point Construction Can Help You Make the Right Roofing Choice
At Four Point Construction, we specialize in installing and maintaining cedar roofs across Minneapolis and beyond. We understand how to work with cedar the right way—from choosing high-quality materials to ensuring proper ventilation and protection against the elements.
Why Trust Us with Your Cedar Roof?
🔹 Extensive experience with cedar roofing installations
🔹 Minneapolis weather expertise
🔹 Honest answers to all your roofing questions
🔹 Free inspections to assess current roof conditions
🔹 High-quality craftsmanship and customer-first service
Whether you’re trying to verify the facts or ready to install a new cedar roof, our team is here to guide you every step of the way.
Ready to Learn More About Cedar Roofing?
Don’t let cedar roofing misconceptions steer you away from a truly outstanding roofing option. Let our experts at Four Point Construction show you the benefits firsthand.
Get a free inspection now and find out whether a cedar roof is the right fit for your home, style, and budget.
